5 Savory Substitute For Brown Mustard That You Can’t Ignored

Brown mustard – isn’t it a distinctive yet versatile addition that can replace cumin, chili powder, chili peppers, and so many more?

You love it and have been using it for a very long time. So, now you want to try out some substitute for brown mustard to bring a whole new flavor to your familiar dishes.

Which substitute is the best option for you? Let’s break the below substitutes down and decide which is your perfect replacement.

The Best Substitute For brown Mustard

Yellow mustard and cayenne

1. Whole Grain Mustard

A regular mustard to replace the spicy brown mustard, the whole grain mustard (or stone-ground mustard) would be an award-winning option. 

To make the typical whole grain mustard recipe, start with grinding down your favorable types of mustard seeds (such as yellow and black mustard seeds) with a stone mill and add white wine to the mixture.

Due to the unique grainy texture and strong flavor, whole grain mustard is a widely-used condiment to bring fantastic mouthfeel and flavor enhancement for various dishes, including sandwiches, hearty dark breads.

2. Yellow Mustard And Cayenne

You want a type of mustard that comes with a mild taste? Then, yellow mustard would be the perfect spicy brown mustard substitute to drizzle on many different food types, such as hot dogs, burgers, French fries, and salads.

The main ingredients of this brown mustard replacement are yellow mustard seeds (also known as white mustard seeds), vinegar, and turmeric – the secret factor that brings it a distinctive bright yellow appearance.

What’s about the mustard flavor?

The traditional version of this mustard brings a milder flavor compared to other types. So, if you want to kick start your taste buds, this mustard type is a solid starting point.

However, if you prefer spicier mustard, you can experiment with something else. For instance, some manufacturers add cayenne or chili peppers to this substitute to increase the spice level and thereby give your food a tangier taste.

3. Dijon Mustard

Dijon mustard is usually known as the best substitute for brown mustard; some people even mistake them to be the same since they both provide such distinctive pungent flavor.

However, they are very different except for the main spicy brown mustard ingredients – brown mustard seeds. 

So, how does Dijon mustard differ from brown mustard?

Well, the first and most essential difference is the liquid used in each mustard production.

For brown mustard, it is vinegar, but for Dijon mustard, the secret liquid is verjuice – the acidic juice of unripe grapes.

However, today, most Dijon-style mustards use white wine rather than the traditional grape juice as white wine is much easier to find while bringing a similar flavor.

Additionally, while Dijon mustard comes with a smooth texture, the brown mustard is a little bit coarser because of its whole and partially ground grains.

Besides, people might use turmeric, cinnamon, or ginger, to boost Dijon mustard substitutes’ flavor and heat. However, rarely does anyone do that to Dijon.

4. Horseradish

If you are looking for a hot mustard similar to spicy brown mustard sauce, then horseradish sauce will be the best replacement because of its nice burn. Just one taste, and you will feel the pungent heat go straight to your nasal passages.

The horseradish sauce goes well with various vegetables, including potatoes, beets, peas, broccoli, and leeks. However, the traditional way to use this substitute is to spice up roast beef. Try it out, and its level of heat will blow your mind away!

In case you prefer to diversify the spice flavor, you can go for sumac – a spice with an intense tart and citrusy flavor. 

This sweet and sour taste, followed by the intense pungency, will elevate your dish into a fancy and make you yearn for more.

5. Honey Mustard

If you have a sweet tooth, why don’t you go for sweet mustards? They are all fantastic mixtures of sweet and tangy.

Among various kinds of sweet mustards, honey mustard is the most common one. Its recipe collection is as diverse as that of a spicy brown mustard recipe.

Anyone can quickly make this mustard mixture from scratch using simple-to-find ingredients like honey, mustard seeds (usually yellow mustard seeds), vinegar, and so on.

And the best part is that this incredibly sweet, tangy, and creamy mustard can be used in countless ways, savoring the roast pork, turning into a dipping sauce and salad dressing, to name a few. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Prepared Brown Mustard?

Prepared mustards in general and prepared brown mustard in specific, are ready-made store-bought mustards you can buy in a bottle or a jar.

Buying this one will save you a lot of time on processing brown mustard seeds and mixing them with various ingredients, right? It also helps to transform one dish from being stale to spectacularly spicy.

However, if you want to adjust the spice depending on your taste, we suggest that you follow the home-made brown mustard recipe. In this way, you can customize the ingredients, such as adding chipotle powder, to create your desired heat.

Is Brown Mustard Good For You?

The grown mustard seeds belong to a nutrient-filled plant so indeed they bring many health benefits. For instance, they contain many minerals, such as calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, iron, and potassium, according to the USDA.

Besides, since the amount of spicy brown mustard calories is quite low, it would be an ideal substitute for many types of rich-in-calories condiments, such as mayonnaise.

Although this mustard is beneficial to your health, you should only use it as a condiment. Otherwise, you can suffer from some harmful side effects, such as mustard allergies or nutrient overload when using it too often.


Is brown mustard good for you

Now you know there are many different brow mustard replacements, such as whole grain mustard, yellow mustard, Dijon mustard, horseradish mustard, and honey mustard.

Each type of substitute for brown mustard has its unique flavor that goes well with different types of food. So, consider the information in this article to select the most suitable replacement and make your dishes more appetizing.

Lastly, thank you very much for reading. If you still have any questions about these substitutes or want to suggest another replacement, please share it in the comment section. We always love to listen to you.

Kevin Richard

Hi all! I’m Kevin. I spend plenty of time in the kitchen every day because I love cooking healthy and delicious foods for my family and friends. Cooking gives me a chance to be creative and fun. It’s also one of the most meaningful ways to express my love and take care of my little family.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 1 comments
  • Leave a Reply: