Why Do Cupcakes Sink In The Middle – Top 7 Common Mistakes To Avoid

You follow the basic cake recipe, fill the liners, and pop them in the oven. Then you patiently wait for the cupcakes to be baked perfectly.  At first, they look beautiful, but then they quickly become flat when you take them out of the oven.

Why do cupcakes sink in the middle? Is there anything you can do to save the sunken cupcakes? Let’s check out our article to discover the detailed answers to your questions.

Why Do Cupcakes Sink In The Middle – Top Common Mistakes Amateur Baker Usually Has


Why do my cupcakes sink in the middle? Several reasons for dropping cupcakes are adding imprecise amounts of ingredients, mixing the batter in the wrong way, overfilling the liners, or baking the cakes at an improper temperature.

Now we will explain the conundrum “why do cupcakes sink in the middle?” in detail.

1. Add Too Much Liquid In The Cake Batter

To create perfect cupcakes, you need to balance the amount of liquid and dry ingredients. Well, liquid content brings moisture to the cakes. However, adding too much liquid, such as skim milk or buttermilk, to the mixture can make the batter too heavy for the dry ingredients to support.

Once the cakes aren’t tough enough, the rising of air bubbles can lead to a collapse. This is what makes cupcakes fall.

2. Add Too Much Or Too Little Baking Powder And Baking Soda

Baking powder or baking soda is what makes cupcakes rise. However, if you measure them by eye and add the proper amount of them to the cake mix, they can be the reasons for the sunken cupcakes.

Well, adding too little baking powder/soda makes your cupcakes difficult to rise. Thus, you make your cupcakes flat once finished.

On the contrary, using too many leavening agents causes the batter to overflow and get deflated. For these reasons, it is a must to measure the exact amount of leavening agents that your recipe calls for. 

3. Don’t Follow The Recipe For Beginner Cupcake Makers

Why do cupcakes fall in the middle? This might happen because you don’t stick to the cupcake recipes. When the cupcake recipe calls for an ingredient you don’t have, you swap it with something you have in the kitchen, right?

This substitution can lead to the flat cupcakes. For instance, it’s okay to replace orange extract with orange juice as this only alters the flavor a little bit.

However, substituting natural cocoa powder with dutch-process cocoa powder when making chocolate cupcakes can ruin the texture of your cake dish, as these powders are far different from each other.

Hence, follow the recipe and be careful with your alternative.

4. Overfill The Cupcake Paper Liner

Overfilling the cupcake cups causes the cakes to have no space left to expand and collapse as soon as you get them out of the oven.

So, which is the proper level for filling the cupcake liner? You should fill your cupcake cavities from ½ to ¾ of the way full, depending on your specific cupcake recipes

5. Mix The Ingredient Improperly

Why do my cupcakes sink? Mixing the ingredients improperly can lead to this issue.

If you don’t beat the eggs or cream your butter well in the mixing bowl, your cakes might not have enough aeration to rise and reach the desired shape.

On the other hand, overmixing basic ingredients may cause too much air incorporated into the cupcake batter. Once your cake mix gets aerated, the cakes will become quite tough and unpleasantly chewy.

So, how to keep cupcakes from falling? The key is to always combine the ingredients at a low to medium-low speed and stop just as they all blend well.

6. Leave The Baking Temperature Too High

Oven temperature is crucial; however, the oven might be finicky. Sometimes, it does not say the proper temperature it is at. If you don’t bake the cakes at the proper temperature, the cakes will either undercooked or dropped in the middle.

In this case, how to keep cupcakes from deflating? Well, you’ll need an oven thermometer to know the exact internal temperature of the oven. Hence, you can preheat the oven and bake cupcakes at the correct temperature.

7. Take The Cakes Out Of The Oven Too Early

Why are my cupcakes sinking in the middle? This issue might happen because you take the cakes out of the oven too early. Thus, they don’t have enough bake time to set up.

If you open the oven door while the cakes are baking, some heat might get out, and a blast of cold air might go into the oven. The dramatic change in temperature makes the uncooked part of the cupcakes fall in no time.

Thus, it would be best to avoid opening the oven door too early or too sharply.

How To Save The Cupcakes That Sink In The Middle?

Cupcakes Sink In The Middle

My cupcakes are flat, so how to save cakes sinking in the middle? Here, let us reveal some useful tips to turn your dropped cupcake into a beautiful sweet treat.

The first method is for the minor sinking. In this situation, let’s top the cakes with cream, cream cheese, or your favorite types of frosting to create delicious frosted cupcakes.

In case the sinkage is quite bad, it would be best to dig out the uncooked part and decorate the rest with anything you want.

For instance, once you have taken the middle, your sunken cupcake will resemble a ring. Then, you can cover the center with fruit, chocolate chips and decorate the top with icing or cream cheese. This way, you’ll have flavorful mini cupcakes in minutes.

Wrapping Up

Here you know the answers to your question – why do cupcakes sink in the middle. Take note of these mistakes and avoid them in the next baking time.

Also, if you have made some dropped cupcakes, use the tips above to rescue and turn them into beautiful cupcakes.

Aside from the question – why do cupcakes fall, do you have any other queries about the cupcakes? Please let us know, and we will do our best to support you.

Kevin Richard

Hi all! I’m Kevin. I spend plenty of time in the kitchen every day because I love cooking healthy and delicious foods for my family and friends. Cooking gives me a chance to be creative and fun. It’s also one of the most meaningful ways to express my love and take care of my little family.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 1 comments
  • Leave a Reply: